Thursday, August 16, 2007

Margalit, Special Reserve, 2001

Eldad Levi was rather harsh on this wine on his (Hebrew) site and the question was, would I (should I) be any harsher? Well, he's a professional and, when he wants to, quite adept at walking a (sometimes thin) line between sarcasm and diplomacy. Sadly, however, this wine did not inspire me to attempt a similar feat of acrobacy.

Simply put, this is a well made bad wine. I tasted it four years ago but I was in a different place then and much less experienced. Therefore, I won't discuss its past. And since I don't have the skills right now to make an edcuated guess about its future, I can only talk about the present.

And its present is miserable. A rich nose with chocolate, burnt wood and meat over a nice currant background would be a nice place to start if I didn't have to actually drink the stuff but while I can usually live peacefully with the oak in Margalit's wines, this time it was way too much. It's not even even a young wine's "look, I'll be outta here in a few years" oaky, it's a middle aged wine's oak that's here to stay. Alright, I realize I am trying to predict this wine's future and I just admitted I don't have the skills for that, but I just can't sense any fruit just biding it's time in there.

For fans of the style only!

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hi Chaim,
I haven't tried the Special Reserve, but liked the standard 2001 Cab. This was a while back but i do recall dark supple fruit coming through. Perhaps the Std benefits from less time in oak?

Arieh

2GrandCru said...

I prefered the regular Cab, too. But it doesn't sepend less time in oak and I recall a Distinguished Reader telling me barrels of the same age are used for both wines. Go figure.

Lewis said...

Hi guys - I don't think the Petite Sirah component does any favor to the Cabernet flavors - it just adds color and tannins. Unfortunately that's enough for some speople to think more highly of it! The "regular" Margalit Cabernet Sauvignon is usually a better wine for my taste, by a good margin.